Subversion Repositories or1k

UDMA information for kernels 2.0.35+

Version 0.4 - July 98
by Andrew D. Balsa <andrebalsa@altern.org>

If you are in a hurry, skip to the "How does one use UDMA support?" section.

If you need troubleshooting advice, check the "Unreliable drive +
motherboard + driver combination" section.

Support for UDMA is based on previous work by Kim-Hoe Pang and Christian
Brunner, posted on the Linux Kernel mailing list around September 1997.
Additional code was provided by Michel Aubry (VIA support) and Andre Hedrick
(support for various PCI UDMA controller cards). The code base is Mark
Lord's triton.c driver.

Check the Linux UDMA mini-HOWTO by Brion Vibber first! It is the only Linux
specific document available on the subject.

Technical references:
a) The Intel 82371AB data sheet, available in PDF format.
b) The SiS 5598 and 5591 data sheets, available in Microsoft Word format. :(
c) The VIA 82C586, 82C586A and 82C586B data sheets, in PDF format.
d) Small Form Factor document SFF 8038I v1.0. This is the original document
   that describes the DMA mode 2 protocol. Available in PDF format.
e) The ATA/ATAPI-4 Working Draft, revision 17. This is document
   d1153r17.pdf (in PDF format), available from the main IDE technical
   reference site, ftp://fission.dt.wdc.com/pub/standards. This draft
   describes the Ultra DMA protocol and timings.

A somewhat less technical, but still very informative document is the
Enhanced IDE/Fast-ATA/ATA-2 FAQ, by John Wehman and Peter den Haan. Check
the Web page at http://come.to/eide.  

**************************************************************************

Files changed
-------------

Here is the set of files from Linux kernels 2.0.32/2.0.34 modified to enable
UDMA transfers on motherboard chipsets that support it. For each file, there
is a small explanation of the changes.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
The following changes do not affect performance or stability of the IDE
driver in any way.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

/drivers/block/triton.c

 - removed some Intel specific timing stuff. This should not affect
driver operation or performance. This is the only file that is heavily
modified; the Promise and Artop code is by Andre Hedrick, the VIA code
by Michel Aubry.

/drivers/block/ide.c

 - added UDMA drive reporting during driver initialization, at the end
of routine do_identify (single line mod).

 - added data for SiS 5513 and VIA VP-1 chipset in routine probe_for_hwifs
(single line mods). Each new UDMA capable chipset will have to be added to
this list (a single line is needed each time). Notice that you don't even
need the motherboard chipset's data sheets to find the needed information.
You just have to identify the IDE controller. You can do this by checking
/proc/pci, and then comparing the IDE controller signature with that
available from the Linux kernel.

As it stands in this patched version, routine probe_for_hwifs supports the
following chipsets: Intel FX, HX, VX, TX, LX and SiS 5513 (which is
integrated in the SiS 5571, 5598 and 5591 chips). The VIA-VP1
chipset is supported for DMA mode 2 transfers, but compatibility has not
been tested with this driver. The VIA MVP-3 is reported OK with UDMA.

/drivers/block/ide.h

 - added flag using_udma in struct ide_drive_s (single line mod). 

Small changes to the tape and ide-floppy code, and additions to pci.h and
pci.c for the extra PCI UDMA controller devices.


Tested configurations
---------------------

UDMA support has been thoroughly tested on the following configurations:

Intel TX motherboard, PCI bus at 33 and 37.5MHz. (ASUS TX-97E)

SiS 5598 motherboards, PCI bus at 33 and 37.5MHz. (Chaintech P5-SDA; ASUS
SP-97V at 33MHz only)

IBM DeskStar 6.4Gb and 8.4Gb drives. Samsung UDMA hard disk proved
unreliable under Linux _and_ Windows95 (so it was not a driver problem).
Other UDMA drives not tested.

libc5 and gcc2.7.2. Also tested under libc6 (RedHat 5.0).

6x86MX processor running at 166MHz or 187.5MHz.

DANGER: EIDE drives do not accept a PCI bus at 41.5MHz (83MHz / 2). Trying
to run DMA Mode 2 or UDMA at these PCI bus clocks will result in crashes and
loss of data. If your FSB runs at > 75MHz you MUST set the PCI bus for
asynchronous 33MHz operation. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED.

Andre Hedrick Tests [IMPORTANT: those are SMP configurations]
-------------------------------------------------------------

Test I
------

Tyan Tomcat III bios v4.01 SMP Dual P5 200 w/ Artop AEC6210 w/ DMA2 drives

Intel MultiProcessor Specification v1.4
    Virtual Wire compatibility mode.
OEM ID: OEM00000 Product ID: PROD00000000 APIC at: 0xFEE00000
Processor #0 Pentium(tm) APIC version 17
Processor #1 Pentium(tm) APIC version 17
I/O APIC #2 Version 17 at 0xFEC00000.
Processors: 2

Linux version 2.0.34 (root@Zosma) (gcc version 2.8.1) #1 Mon Jun 8 16:40:25 CDT
Booting processor 1 stack 00002000: Calibrating delay loop.. ok - 79.67
BogoMIPSTotal of 2 processors activated (159.33 BogoMIPS).
Starting kswapd v 1.4.2.2

ide: DMA Bus Mastering IDE controller on PCI bus 0 function 57
ide: ports are not enabled (BIOS)
ide: AEC6210 ROM enabled but no address
ide: UDMA Bus Mastering IDE controller on PCI bus 0 function 160
ide: timings == 04010401
    ide0: BM-DMA at 0x6700-0x6707
    ide1: BM-DMA at 0x6708-0x670f
hda: Maxtor 72004 AP, 1916MB w/128kB Cache, CHS=973/64/63, DMA
hdb: Maxtor 71626 A, 1554MB w/64kB Cache, CHS=789/64/63, DMA
hdc: IOMEGA ZIP 100 ATAPI, ATAPI FLOPPY drive
hdd: HP COLORADO 5GB, ATAPI TAPE drive
ide-tape: Sorry, DRQ types other than Accelerated DRQ
ide-tape: are still not supported by the driver
ide-tape: the tape is not supported by this version of the driver
ide2: ports already in use, skipping probe
ide0 at 0x6300-0x6307,0x6402 on irq 11
ide1 at 0x6500-0x6507,0x6602 on irq 11 (shared with ide0)
scsi0 : ncr53c8xx - revision 2.5f.1

Test II
-------

SuperMicro P6DNF SMP Dual P6 233 w/ Artop AEC6210 and Promise Ultra33

Intel MultiProcessor Specification v1.4
    Virtual Wire compatibility mode.
OEM ID: INTEL    Product ID: 440FX        APIC at: 0xFEE00000
Processor #0 Pentium(tm) Pro APIC version 17
Processor #1 Pentium(tm) Pro APIC version 17
I/O APIC #2 Version 17 at 0xFEC00000.
Processors: 2

Linux version 2.0.34 (root@Orion) (gcc version 2.8.1) #1 Wed Jun 17 01:13:15 CDT 1998
Booting processor 1 stack 00002000: Calibrating delay loop.. ok - 232.65 BogoMIPS
Total of 2 processors activated (464.49 BogoMIPS).

ide: Intel 82371 (single FIFO) DMA Bus Mastering IDE
    Controller on PCI bus 0 function 57
ide: ports are not enabled (BIOS)
ide: AEC6210 ROM enabled at 0xfebf8000
ide: PCI UDMA Bus Mastering IDE
    Controller on PCI bus 0 function 160
ide: timings == 04010401
    ide0: BM-DMA at 0xef90-0xef97
    ide1: BM-DMA at 0xef98-0xef9f
hda: QUANTUM FIREBALL ST3.2A, 3079MB w/81kB Cache, CHS=782/128/63, UDMA
hdb: QUANTUM FIREBALL ST6.4A, 6149MB w/81kB Cache, CHS=784/255/63, UDMA
hdc: IOMEGA ZIP 100 ATAPI, ATAPI FLOPPY drive
hdd: CD-ROM CDU611, ATAPI CDROM drive
ide2: ports already in use, skipping probe
ide0 at 0xeff0-0xeff7,0xefe6 on irq 10
ide1 at 0xefa8-0xefaf,0xefe2 on irq 10 (shared with ide0)

Test III
--------

Same kernel above but with Promise Ultra33

ide: Intel 82371 (single FIFO) DMA Bus Mastering IDE
    Controller on PCI bus 0 function 57
ide: ports are not enabled (BIOS)
ide: PDC20246 ROM enabled at 0xfebd0000
ide: PCI UDMA Bus Mastering IDE
    Controller on PCI bus 0 function 160
ide: timings == 000003ee
    ide0: BM-DMA at 0xef80-0xef87
    ide1: BM-DMA at 0xef88-0xef8f
hda: QUANTUM FIREBALL ST3.2A, 3079MB w/81kB Cache, CHS=782/128/63, UDMA
hdb: QUANTUM FIREBALL ST6.4A, 6149MB w/81kB Cache, CHS=784/255/63, UDMA
hdc: IOMEGA ZIP 100 ATAPI, ATAPI FLOPPY drive
hdd: CD-ROM CDU611, ATAPI CDROM drive
ide2: ports already in use, skipping probe
ide0 at 0xeff0-0xeff7,0xefe6 on irq 10
ide1 at 0xefa8-0xefaf,0xebe6 on irq 10 (shared with ide0)

All tests cases yield this problem, IOMEGA ZIP 100 ATAPI FW 23.D
I have a patch fix for 2.1.99->106 similar for FW 21.D drives.

ide-floppy: hdc: I/O error, pc = 5a, key =  5, asc = 24, ascq =  0
ide-floppy: Can't get drive capabilities

Note that both AEC6210 and PDC20246 have onboard bios that auto-config.


What UDMA support does
----------------------

        - It enables UDMA transfers on the Intel TX chipset.
        - It enables DMA mode2 transfers on the SiS 5571 and VIA VP-1
          (82C586) chipsets.
        - It enables DMA mode2 and UDMA mode2 transfers on the SiS 5598 and
          SiS 5591 chipsets, and the VIA VP3 and MVP-3.
        - With single line mods for each new chipset, it will support any DMA
          mode2 and/or UDMA capable chipset compatible with document
          SFF 8038I v1.0.
        - Supports a variety of PCI UDMA controller cards.


Support for other chipsets
--------------------------

It is relatively easy to add support for other chipsets. Some chipsets are
entirely integrated (e.g. the SiS 5598 chipset has various devices in a
single chip), others are divided into a Northbridge (CPU to PCI circuitry,
L2 cache control, etc) and Southbridge (PCI to IDE bus mastering interface,
USB, etc). We are dealing here with the Southbridge, specifically with the
IDE bus master PCI device. If the data sheet says the device is SFF 8038I
v1.0 compatible, then the registers have a more or less standard layout and
this driver should work with the below changes:

1) Check that the chipset is correctly identified by /proc/pci. Search for
the line that identifies a bus-mastering IDE controller device.

2) If the chipset is not correctly identified (new chipsets are not in
kernels up to 2.0.33), you will need to edit /include/linux/pci.h and
/drivers/pci/pci.c. This is actually quite easy, requiring a single line in
each of these files.

3) Now add a single line to ide.c, in routine probe_for_hwifs.

4) Test and report results; when troubleshooting, please check first that
you have the latest BIOS for your motherboard. 


HOW does UDMA mode2 work?
-------------------------

Well, actually, the excellent triton.c driver written by Mark Lord is a
generic DMA transfer hard disk driver. It does not depend on any chipset
feature or transfer mode (i.e. it will work with DMA mode 2, UDMA and other
future DMA modes with little or no changes). BTW in late 2.1.x kernels the
driver was renamed ide-dma.c, to indicate that it is independent of the
chipset used.

(Note: triton is the "old" name for the Intel FX chipset, for which Mark
Lord wrote the driver initially.)

The Intel chipset specific parts were slightly changed in the triton.c
driver. These are only used to gather information for driver testing, and
actually do not affect the operation or performance of the driver, so the
changes are (well, should be) relatively inocuous.

The real work involved in setting up the chips for DMA transfers is done
mostly by the BIOS of each motherboard. Now of course one hopes that the
BIOS has been correctly programmed...

For example, the ASUS SP-97V motherboard with its original BIOS (Rev. 1.03)
would malfunction with the modified Linux driver in both DMA mode 2 and UDMA
modes; it would work well using PIO mode 4, or under Windows 95 in all
modes. I downloaded the latest BIOS image (Rev. 1.06) from the ASUS Web site
and flashed the BIOS EPROM with the latest BIOS revision. It has been
working perfectly ever since (at 66 MHz bus speeds).

What this tells us is that the BIOS sets up the DMA controller with specific
timing parameters (active pulse and recovery clock cycles). My initial BIOS
revision probably had bad timings. Since the Windows 95 driver sets up those
timings by itself (i.e. it does not depend on the BIOS to setup the hard
disk controller timing parameters), I initially had problems only with the
Linux driver, while Windows 95 worked well.

So, let me state this again: this Linux (U)DMA driver depends on the BIOS for
correct (U)DMA controller setup. If you have problems, first check that you
have the latest BIOS revision for your specific motherboard.

OTOH Michel Aubry's code for the VIA Apollo chipset has complete support for
setting up the timing parameters. Check the triton.c source code for
details.

New BIOS revisions can be downloaded from your motherboard manufacturer's
Web site. Flashing a new BIOS image is a simple operation but one must
strictly follow the steps explained on the motherboard manual.

Late Award BIOS revisions seem stable with respect to UDMA. Anything with a
date of 1998 should be fine.


Features missing from the present UDMA support code
---------------------------------------------------

It does not set UDMA transfer parameters (the driver assumes the BIOS has
correctly setup all timing parameters) in the various chipsets. This
requires access to a complete set of data sheets for the various chipsets,
and testing on a variety of configurations, so it's not exactly within the
reach of a humble Linux hacker. IMHO this is best left to the guys at Award
and AMI (the BIOS guys), and to the motherboard engineers.

Basically, UDMA transfers depend on two timing parameters:
        1) The pulse width of the active strobe signal for data transfers
(usually described as the active pulse width).
        2) The delay between the negation of the DMA READY signal to the
assertion of STOP when the IDE controller wants to stop a read operation
(usually described as the recovery time).

Both timing parameters can be set individually for each hard disk (up to two
hard disks per channel).

Knowing which registers must hold this data and the appropriate values, one
could program the Linux triton.c driver to setup the IDE controller device,
without relying on BIOS settings. However, some chipsets allow setting other
timing parameters, and the required code would quickly increase to a
not-so-easy-to-manage size. Better keep it simple, IMHO.

It seems Mark Lord has devised a neat way to do this in the ide-dma driver
included in late kernels 2.1.x: each chipset has an entry in a table, with
safe timing values. The chipset is also identified when the driver is
loaded.


How does one use UDMA support?
------------------------------

1) Backup your data or you will be sorry. Now do "hdparm -t -T
/dev/hda". Write a small note with the transfer rates you see.

2) Reboot. Press [Del] to launch the CMOS SETUP routine, go to the
CHIPSET SPECIFIC or PERIPHERALS SETUP menus, and enable UDMA transfers
for your hard disk drives which are UDMA capable, or leave the fields in
the default "AUTO" value. Enable both IDE channels even if you have just
one IDE drive (default setting).

3) Boot Linux, compile the kernel with the TRITON support enabled. Install
the new kernel (the lilo thingy). Reboot Linux.

4) Watch for the drive parameters message when the kernel loads (or type
"dmesg | more" after login). After the Cyl, Heads, Sect parameters you
should see "DMA" or "UDMA" depending on your hard disk drive and chipset
capabilities.

Here is what I get with UDMA enabled in the BIOS of my SiS 5598 based
configuration, with an IBM UDMA capable hard disk as hda:

...
ide: DMA Bus Mastering IDE controller on PCI bus 0 function 9
    ide0: BM-DMA at 0x4000-0x4007
    ide1: BM-DMA at 0x4008-0x400f
hda: IBM-DHEA-36480, 6197MB w/476kB Cache, LBA, CHS=790/255/63, UDMA
...

If I disable UDMA in the BIOS, I get:

...
ide: DMA Bus Mastering IDE controller on PCI bus 0 function 9
    ide0: BM-DMA at 0x4000-0x4007
    ide1: BM-DMA at 0x4008-0x400f
hda: IBM-DHEA-36480, 6197MB w/476kB Cache, LBA, CHS=790/255/63, DMA
...

5) Again, do "hdparm -t -T /dev/hda". Smile. Test your setup by copying
a few large files around or doing some large compilation (e.g. the Linux
kernel itself).


Performance issues
------------------

1) Sustained transfer rates.

Here is some data gathered after extensive testing, using the hdparm utility
(also written by Mark Lord):

PIO mode 4 transfer rates under Linux:   +/- 5.2MB/s

DMA mode 2 transfer rates under Linux:   +/- 7.2MB/s

UDMA mode 2 transfer rates under Linux:  +/- 9.8MB/s

Data gathered on a Chaintech SiS 5598 motherboard, 6x86MX @ 187.5MHz, Linux
2.0.32/2.0.33 with patched triton.c driver as explained above, IBM DeskStar
6.4GB hard disk (IBM-DHEA-36480).

The integrated video hardware in the SiS 5598 chip was disabled (a standard
PCI video board was used); enabling the integrated SVGA controller will
cause a 20% performance hit in processing performance, due to limited main
memory bandwidth.

The TX motherboard under the same test conditions will be slightly
slower (0.1 - 0.2 MB/s slower).

Burst (instantaneous) transfer rates are supposed to go from 16.6MB/s (PIO
mode 4) to 16.6MB/s (DMA mode 2) up to 33MB/s (UDMA). In his patch against
kernel 2.1.55, Kim-Hoe Pang actually checked the UDMA burst transfer rate
with a logic analiser: 60ns/word, which translates into 33MB/s.

Note that burst transfer rates only affect data transfers to/from the EIDE
drive cache (476kB for the IBM 6.4GB drive), and IMHO are not particularly
relevant for most Linux users.

The Linux kernel uses as much RAM as possible to cache hard disk data
accesses, and so if data is not in the kernel cache there is little chance
that it will be in the (much smaller) hard disk cache.

2) Processor utilization

Unfortunately, it is very difficult to gather data about processor
utilization during data transfers, but this is exactly the biggest advantage
of DMA transfers over PIO transfers. My estimate is that CPU utilization
during UDMA transfers will be as low as 3-4%, while being somewhere around
30% for PIO transfers and 6-8% for DMA mode 2.

3) UDMA vs SCSI

The main advantage of DMA mode 2 and UDMA over SCSI is that the controller
is already on your motherboard, so why not use it?

Mark Lord's triton.c driver has a very small latency and so UDMA drives
may beat their Ultra-Wide SCSI-2 counterparts in some cases (at equal
spindle speeds) e.g. lots of small files (loaded news servers) being
read/written at irregular intervals.

Note however that SCSI drives are available at spindle speeds of 7,200,
10,000 and even a recently announced 12,030 rpm. IBM is planning some 7,200
rpm UDMA EIDE drives, but those are not yet available. Seagate has just
released its EIDE 7,200 rpm drives, but they have special cooling
requirements just like their SCSI counterparts. Expect this technology to
become commonplace by the end of 98, though.

The UDMA burst data transfer rates exceed maximum head transfer rates
(maximum head transfer rates in the industry have reached 160 Mbits/s in
1998) and so for large files neither Ultra-Wide SCSI-2 nor UDMA will have an
advantage over the other technology.

It used to be that high-capacity drives were only available with SCSI
interfaces, but this isn't true anymore. Right now top capacity for an EIDE
drive is Maxtor's 11.3Gb monster, which is quite affordable in fact. One can
drive four of these with a standard motherboard: 45Gb for < $2k.

SCSI drives can chain, overlap and re-order commands, EIDE drives cannot.
However, Linux already has an intelligent "elevator" algorithm for hard disk
accesses.

At present, EIDE top speed is 33MB/s burst. Ultra-Wide II SCSI is 80MB/s
burst. The cost of an Ultra-Wide II SCSI controller + 9Gb hard disk is > 4 x
the cost of an 8GB UDMA drive. IMHO the price/performance ratio of UDMA
beats SCSI.

A new standard is emerging called ATA-66, which will double the burst
transfer speed of EIDE drives to 66Mb/s. I don't have any technical info
about it, unfortunately. The first ATA-66 drives will be shipped by Quantum
in 1999, but VIA has already announced two ATA-66 capable chipsets (in fact
based on the same Southbridge chip); as I write this, data sheets are not
available to the general public. Probably Intel will come out with a chipset
of its own with ATA-66 capabilities.

4) What is the best UDMA chipset/hard disk?

Intel designed the first DMA mode 2 capable chipset, the FX (Triton I) a few
years ago. The Linux DMA mode 2 driver was initially written by Mark Lord
for the original Intel FX chipset and appeared around kernel 1.3.20 if I
remember well. The later HX and VX chipsets had exactly the same DMA mode 2
capabilities and the triton.c driver was for a long time Intel-only. Mark
planned to support the Opti Viper chipset but Opti went out of the
motherboard chipset business so fast that Mark didn't even have the time to
get his hands on an Opti motherboard, I guess.

Intel later introduced a UDMA compatible motherboard chipset with its TX
chipset. Kernel 2.0.31 was the first Linux kernel to support the TX chipset,
however only DMA mode 2 (16.6MB/s) was supported.

The TX chipset has a proven record of reliability. But DMA mode 2 and UDMA
transfers on the TX suffer from a flaw common to previous Intel DMA mode 2
only chipsets: a single data buffer is shared between the two IDE channels.
This buffer (64 bytes deep) is used to hold data on its way from the PCI bus
to/from the hard disk's small cache. A hardware arbitration mechanism
prevents data loss when the OS tries to simultaneously use both IDE
channels.

VIA chips also have a single FIFO, with the same 64 bytes deep buffer.
However, VIA chips can have the buffer split 1:1 or 3:1 between both IDE
channels; an interesting feature, but difficult to use.

How is this FIFO buffer used? Remember that the PCI bus can transfer data at
a maximum rate of 132MB/s when clocked at 33MHz, 150MB/s when clocked at
37.5MHz (maximum safe clock speed for PCI is 33MHz, after that well..). So the
PCI bus mastering IDE controller will be transfering data from main memory
DRAM to this FIFO buffer in small bursts of < 64 bytes, then from the buffer
to the IDE disk drive cache (when writing; the other way around for reads).

I recently managed to get hold of the SiS 5598 data sheet and studied the
IDE controller part of this highly integrated chip, a device identified by
the number 5513. The 5598 even includes an SVGA controller, which should be
disabled if one wants to get decent performance from this chipset: it
severely limits CPU/memory bandwidth. The SiS5597 is the same part with
a different pinout.

It appears the 5513 has two completely independent IDE channels, each with
its own 64 bytes deep data buffer. On disk-to-disk or CD-to-disk transfers,
the 5598 and 5591 chipsets will easily beat the Intel TX and VIA. On
simultaneous (U)DMA transfers to two disks (for example, when the Linux md
driver is used to create a RAID-0 array with data striping), the 5513 device
will be faster than the TX Southbridge device since there will be no
contention for the data buffer, assuming each drive is connected to a
different IDE channel.  Other PCI bus related features will also improve its
performance of the SiS devices. So, compared to the Intel TX and various VIA
chipsets, the 5598 and 5591 win hands down in terms of UDMA implementation.

Unfortunately, it is very difficult to get data sheets for the ALi Aladdin
IV+ and Aladdin V chipsets. These newer chipsets support up to 1 MB of L2
SRAM cache, the AGP bus (2X), 100 MHz CPU bus and of course, UDMA data
transfers. The newest VIA chipset for Socket 7 motherboards beats them all
in terms of features, as it sports ATA-66 compatibility.

On the UDMA hard drive front, the present performance leaders are the IBM
Deskstar drives. These drives have relatively large data caches (476kB
available), a 5,400 rpm rotational speed and < 10ms random access times.
They run very cool and although they can't be called silent, their noise
level is acceptable. They are also reliable.

Seagate has just begun shipping 7,200 rpm EIDE drives which will obviously
benefit from the lower data latency. They are reported as particularly
silent due to the use of Fluid Dynamic Bearing motors, but running quite
hot. IMHO if one has to add a fan to cool them, this defeats any advantage
these drives will have in terms of noise level. Another advantage of this
technology is the lower vibration levels compared to ball bearings.

IBM has pre-announced very large capacity (14GB), 7,200 rpm EIDE UDMA drives
a month ago, but those are not shipping yet. They are based on a new head
technology called Giant Magneto-Resistive Heads, which is supposed to
increase the data density on the disks by a factor of 4 or more. More details
when I get my hands on one. IBM licensed Western Digital to use this
technology.

Quantum has always shipped among the best and fastest EIDE drives, and they
worked with Intel to create the UDMA standard. They used to have the fastest
drives for Linux DMA mode 2 transfers (see the comments in
/Documentation/ide.txt).

Well, I just got an email from Denny de Jonge <denny@luna.nl> that proves
Quantum drives will keep their reputation:

"Andre,

 After I applied the UDMA-patch for Linux 2.0.33 hdparm showed up with the
 following benchmarks:

 /dev/hda:

 Timing buffer-cache reads:   64 MB in  1.02 seconds =62.75 MB/sec
 Timing buffered disk reads:  32 MB in  3.02 seconds =10.60 MB/sec

 Not bad, don't you think ?

 These results have been obtained using the Intel 82371 Chipset and a
 Quantum Fireball 4.3SE harddisk."

I later asked what kind of processor Denny was using: it's a 266MHz PII.

BTW I have been collecting hard disk/file subsystem benchmarking information
based on bonnie, a popular benchmark available for Linux. I have come to the
conclusion that bonnie is not a reliable benchmark when it comes to
comparing different systems, basically because it depends so much on how
much RAM one has installed and how much of it is free, as well as system
load, CPU speed, etc. For this reason I will not quote bonnie results
anymore. For comparative benchmarking between two hard disk drives on
exactly the same hardware it may be acceptable, but otherwise it's too
unreliable as an indicator of performance.


Unreliable drive + motherboard + driver combination
---------------------------------------------------

Quoting Kim-Hoe Pang:

"The UDMA mode of an UDMA drive would NOT be enabled on a non-UDMA capable
chipset mobo. On power-up or after a hardware reset, the drive is in normal
PIO/DMA mode. To enable the UDMA mode in the drive, the host, BIOS or OS,
needs to send a SET FEATURE ("enable UDMA mode subcommand") AT command to
the drive. A non-UDMA capable mobo will not send this command to the drive.

UDMA mode is dis/enabled via BIOS setup. The patch does not attempt to
override user's BIOS setting."

There may be some combinations of drives, motherboards (BIOS) and Linux
driver which may prove unreliable. Remember we are transfering data at
33MB/s over unshielded ribbon cable in a very noisy (electromagnetically
speaking) environment.

In the future it would be nice if hard disk manufacturers would publish the
timings required by their drives, and chipset manufacturers would follow a
single standard for registers and controller architecture. Right now UDMA is
extremely timing sensitive.

A few recommendations for troubleshooting:

1) Make sure you have the latest BIOS for your motherboard. Connect to the
motherboard manufacturer's Web site and download the latest BIOS image file
and EEPROM flashing utilities. Check your BIOS version, and only flash your
EEPROM if needed.

2) Keep the IDE cable going from the motherboard to the drive short, and do
not loop it around another cable. I recommend < 30 cm (12") total cable
length.

3) If you have just a single UDMA hard disk drive per channel (which I
recommend), use the connectors at both ends of the cable to connect
motherboard and drive, do _not_ use the middle connector. If you have a UDMA
hard disk drive and a CD-ROM drive on the same cable, plug the hard disk
drive at the end of the cable (use the middle connector for the CD-ROM
drive). Also the hard disk must be the master EIDE device, the CD-ROM drive
the slave EIDE device, never the other way around (this is not determined by
cable position, but by small jumpers on the drive and at the back of the
CD-ROM). The same rules apply to CD-RW, ZIP and tape EIDE drives.

4) If you have (shudder) Windows 95 installed in your system, and have been
able to use UDMA, you should be able to use UDMA with Linux.

5) DON'T OVERCLOCK the PCI bus. 33MHz is the maximum supported speed for
the PCI bus. Some (supposedly compatible) UDMA drives will not even take
37.5MHz, but should be OK at 33.3MHz.

In any case, NEVER, NEVER set the PCI bus to 41.5MHz.

The RECOMMENDED safe setting is 33MHz.

Adequate testing is needed in each case. The golden rule here, as always:
backup, backup, backup.


Aknowledgments
--------------

Mark Lord for his excellent, reliable and very readable triton.c driver code
and all his (E)IDE Linux programming.

Kim-Hoe Pang for the first UDMA patch against kernel 2.1.55.

Christian Brunner for his patch converting triton.c into a generic DMA mode
2 EIDE driver. 

Brion Vibber for his neat Linux UDMA mini-HOWTO, for his help and
contributions to this package, and for bearing with my various documentation
changes and suggestions.

Michel Aubry for his complete VIA support and neat diagnostics code, as well
as the patch to hdparm to support UDMA.

Andre Hedrick for his great code for the various PCI UDMA controller cards.