OpenCores

1G eth UDP / IP Stack

Issue List
MAC ready/valid handshaking #9
Closed Rythan opened this issue over 11 years ago
Rythan commented over 11 years ago

I ported the UDP/IP stack to a custom Virtex 6 board using an SFP 1000baseX GTX interface. The board would not respond to ARP requests. Via ChipScope, I saw that the ARP packets were being received, but the UDP/IP core's responses were not being transmitted. Further inspection showed that the V6EMAC was keeping tx_axis_mac_tready low, so the ARP module was never setting tx_axis_mac_tvalid high.

Reading UG800 for version 2.2 of the V6EMAC shows that the MAC was behaving as expected (figure 6-8)... tx_axis_mac_tready should go high in response to tx_axis_mac_tvalid going high, and not the other way around. I implemented the UDP/IP example on an ML605 for comparison, which worked. It appears that when using a GMII interface (ML605) instead of a GTX interface (my custom board) the V6EMAC core happens to holds tx_axis_mac_tready high in advance, so this bug doesn't show up in the ML605 example.

I can send you modified code that works (arp_tx.vhd and ipv4_tx.vhd needed corrections).

Thanks for contributing a valuable project!

-Greg

pjf was assigned over 11 years ago
pjf commented over 11 years ago

Hi Greg,

thanks for your post and comments. If you could email me your modifications that would be great. I will then review these and update the stack on OpenCores.

Regards, Peter

paritosh141290 commented over 8 years ago

Hi Peter. You have done an excellent job. I also faced the same problem as Greg. I think the corrections have not been reflected in the updated files.

pjf commented over 8 years ago

Hi Paritosh,

Thanks for your comments. I don't think that I ever received the mods from Greg.

If you are able to supply changes that you have made sucessfully, could you send them to me and I will check and update the project (will be some delay as I have relocated to Australia and my stuff incl FPGA hw is still being shipped).

Regards, Peter

pjf commented almost 7 years ago

Closing due to lack of feedback from originator after 2 years.

pjf closed this almost 7 years ago

Assignee
pjf
Labels
Bug